I consistently switch off my mobile device as I step into a theater. Not simply on silent mode – all the way off. I state this not from a place of judgment, or to imply that the ghost of a film legend will return to shake my hand. I consider it as a genuine small luxuries: for a minimum of a couple of hours, I am totally incommunicado. I maintain my phone deactivated for the duration of the end credits as well. It seems luxurious to remain seated as the audience trickle away, lit only by the scrolling names.
And, more and more, by the light of the Letterboxd application.
Over millions of individuals utilize Letterboxd, a movie-logging app. Similar to the Criterion Collection, it has become a cultural signifier for a certain breed of tastemaker who hypes new releases and revels in rediscovering vintage films. Users score and write about films, and the wittiest or most profound critiques become popular, motivating film lovers to write diligently.
"Unless I get my thoughts out promptly once the movie ends, my reviews are significantly less coherent and articulate," remarked a student.
During a recent outing to the cinema, the end titles had just begun before the gentleman seated in front of me started composing his assessment. Not far away, a duo lingered, looking down, recording their respective thoughts.
The late artist David Lynch had a piece of wisdom: write down every great idea the very second it comes to mind. Otherwise, it could be forgotten, and, in his words: "If you forget a good idea, you feel like you could commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to hopeful creators, a similar ethos fits the act of reviewing.
One young man, a 20-year-old student in New York, always drafts his assessments before leaving the auditorium.
"If I don't articulate my impressions promptly once the movie ends, my write-ups are significantly less coherent and articulate," he explained. "It requires some time. I take my time, and my significant other doesn't like it."
Stern attends the movies frequently – 182 times in a single year – and is on a first-name basis with the theater staff, who sometimes must usher him out so they can commence sweeping the aisles. He believes it acceptable to milk the credit sequence: "When you pay for a theater ticket, the closing sequence are included in the movie."
Letterboxd's most ardent supporters credit the platform with reviving enthusiasm around a battered film industry, where fewer films are made and work is scarce. (Letterboxd also possesses the kind of user profile advertisers seek – its biggest segment of users is between 18 and 24, with those aged 25 to 35.)
Excitement begets additional buzz; highly awaited movies witness a flurry of engagement on Letterboxd right after the initial screenings. The most-liked review of a divisive movie – "Emily Brontë passed away in the 19th century yet this interpretation is still the worst thing that has ever affected her" – has amassed over 50,000 likes. Another recent film inspired this comparison to a major artist's documentary: "a famous concert movie found dead."
"It feels like a compulsion," remarked Ben Glidden, a 33-year-old New Yorker who has a career in marketing. He also chooses to compose critiques throughout the closing scroll. "Processing what you just experienced, as soon as you saw it, enhances the artistic experience. It helps you grasp the core ideas of a film. If it produces a feeling of a warm hug, that's hardly something you recall the next day."
This user feels most compelled to review a film if it was exceptionally good – or exceptionally bad. For example: he recently watched a sci-fi film. "I was so disappointed by how egregiously bad it was, that I was eager to take out my phone and award it a one-half star review," he stated. (He is a more critical evaluator than some professional critics, who gave the film a more favorable review, describing it as "clever and engaging stuff.")
Another user, a 28-year-old professional who manages social media, saw a fantasy animated film at a neighborhood theater and remained to write the write-up ("I gave it five stars"). He has observed poorer etiquette: people whipping out their phones to log the movie they are actively viewing. "That irritates me," he commented.
One of cinema's most enduring urban legends recounts a showing of an 1896 silent short that featured a train arriving at a station. Film was in its infancy and – according to this largely discredited rumor – the image of a locomotive moving right toward the camera shocked the crowd so much that people ran away screaming.
Over a century later, cinema etiquette remains just as questionable. It seems, individuals remember how to act in public anymore, especially when the lights dim: viewers take pictures of the screen, carry in odorous food, and, as seen during a cultural moment, sometimes engage in fights.
Some individuals have taken to social media to debate the acceptability of writing reviews during the closing scroll. When one social media user